For many landlords, it's cheaper to wait than to fix
DC renters often deal with landlords who don't keep their buildings in decent shape. We don't think the problem is a shortage of inspections or citations. It's that enforcement is slow and broken. A violation has to move through three separate offices, and each step takes months or years.
DOBAn inspector cites the violation and sets a fine
OAHThe Office of Administrative Hearings decides if the landlord contests it
CCUThe Central Collection Unit chases the fine if it goes unpaid
Under that system, many landlords find it cheaper to wait out the penalties than to make the repairs. So fines pile up, with $88.7 million in fines on open violations today, and many tenants go years without repairs.
The problem is also concentrated. DC's 50 worst landlords carry more than $22 million in fines on open violations. 52% of open violations are in Wards 7 and 8 alone. Buildings built in 1975 or earlier account for about 89% of violations and fines. Many of them are rent-controlled, where a landlord can have an incentive to let conditions slide and push tenants out.
The approach
Three ways to act
A
Consequences that skip the broken pipeline
Revoke business licenses, block rent increases, collect fines through the tax system, and pursue receivership where needed.
B
Violations that lower the rent
When DOB cites a building and the landlord misses the repair deadline, the rent drops automatically, and tenants can pay into escrow.
C
Stronger tenant organizing
Protect tenants who withhold rent over violations DOB has cited and the landlord hasn't fixed.
Under existing law
What the city can do now
These could be done by the Mayor and city agencies through executive or administrative action.
1
Revoke business licenses for chronic violators
Existing law
Send unaddressed DOB violations to the Department of Licensing and Consumer Protection (DLCP), and use its existing authority to revoke business licenses for negligent landlords. A landlord without a valid business license can't lawfully evict tenants or get a certificate of occupancy (D.C. Code § 42-3505.01).1
DC's regulations already say a business seeking a license "shall allow [DLCP], and any District government agency responsible for enforcement of the housing and building regulations, to inspect its housing business premises" (14 DCMR § 202.1). DLCP is supposed to require that buildings comply with building and housing laws before it grants a license (14 DCMR § 202.3). And DLCP can deny, suspend or revoke a license when the holder doesn't meet the qualifications for it, including compliance with the building code (14 DCMR § 206.4).
Why it works: because landlords can't evict without a license, the threat of losing one could get more repairs made than a fine that arrives years after a failed inspection.2
2
Block rent increases in rent-stabilized buildings with unresolved violations
Existing law
DC's rent stabilization rules say rent "shall not be increased if the unit is not in compliance with the housing code" (14 DCMR § 4200.10). Any increase that needs prior approval "shall not be approved unless" the problem has been fixed by the time of the hearing (§ 4200.9).
Today this only kicks in if a tenant files a petition contesting the increase.
The fix: make the check automatic. Direct the Rent Administrator to screen for open DOB violations before a rent increase takes effect, and use powers the Administrator already has to block increases when the building isn't in compliance with the housing code.
3
Roll back rents in buildings with excessive, prolonged violations
Existing law
The Rent Administrator already has the power to roll back rents where violations have gone on too long:
"Where the Rent Administrator finds there have been excessive and prolonged violations of the housing regulations affecting the health, safety, and security of the tenants or the habitability of the housing accommodation in which the tenants reside and that the housing provider has failed to correct the violations, the Rent Administrator may roll back the rents for the affected rental units to an amount which shall not be less than the September 1, 1983, base rent for the rental units until the violations have been abated."
The fix: as far as we can tell, the Rent Administrator hasn't been using this power. The next Mayor should direct the Rent Administrator to use it, or appoint one who will.
4
Take more landlords to court, and make receivership usable
Existing law
The Office of the Attorney General has occasionally taken owners to court directly, including its RICO suit against the Razjooyan family and its case against Petra Properties. It should dedicate more capacity to the worst repeat offenders.
DC also already allows receivership for distressed buildings, where a court puts someone else in charge of the property, but it's rarely used. The city should map out who can trigger it and build a faster way to refer buildings.
5
Collect fines through the property tax system
Existing law
Let unpaid DOB fines attach to the property as tax liabilities, where DC has much stronger collection tools, so they don't die in the Central Collection Unit.
New legislation
What the Council needs to pass
1
Escalating fines for violations that stay open
New legislation
Today the fine on a DOB Notice of Infraction (NOI) is set when the notice is issued, and it doesn't grow while the violation stays open. A landlord who never makes the repair pays no more than one who makes it late, so waiting out the process costs nothing extra.
The proposal: once the repair deadline on an NOI passes, a daily fine starts adding up automatically for each open violation, with no new inspection or NOI needed. The daily rate rises the longer the violation stays open and stops only when DOB verifies the repair.
Other cities already do this
New York City charges a per-day penalty after the repair deadline until the fix is made.
Portland charges a monthly fee starting 30 days after the notice, doubles it if the violations aren't fixed within three months, keeps charging until the repair is inspected and approved, and records it as a lien on the property.
Salt Lake City treats each day past the deadline as a separate fine, and doubles the daily rate when a property has more than ten violations.
DC should create escalating fines like these, so landlords have a real financial reason to fix their buildings.
2
Automatic rent reduction and escrow for unfixed violations
New legislation
Today, a DC tenant living with an unrepaired violation still owes full rent. To get it lowered, the tenant has to act alone: withhold rent and defend that in eviction court, sue in Housing Conditions Court, or, in a rent-stabilized unit, petition the Rent Administrator. All of these are slow and put the burden on the tenant. Meanwhile the landlord keeps collecting full rent while the violation stays open, which is part of why waiting is cheaper than fixing.
The proposal: when a landlord misses the repair deadline on a DOB notice, rent for the affected units drops automatically. The cut would be a set percentage based on how serious the violations are, and it would last until DOB verifies the repair.
Tenants could pay the reduced rent to the landlord or into a city-run escrow account.
Rent paid into escrow would count as paid, so it couldn't be grounds for eviction.
Escrow money would be released to keep utilities on, pay for repairs or help tenants relocate.
The landlord could contest the reduction at an administrative hearing, but the reduction would stay in place in the meantime.
Other cities already do this
Los Angeles puts a property into its Rent Escrow Account Program (REAP) when it's cited for health, safety or habitability violations and the owner doesn't fix them by the deadline. Rent is cut 10% to 50%, depending on how serious the violations are and the property's history. Escrow money can be released to prevent utility shutoffs, pay for repairs or help tenants who choose to move. A property leaves the program only after a final inspection and City Council approval.
New York takes a similar approach for rent-stabilized units. A state rent-reduction order lowers the rent and bars further increases until the agency finds services restored, though there the process starts with a tenant complaint.
In the meantime, organize
None of this replaces tenants standing together. Tenants who organize win repairs that tenants alone usually don't.